Mug, tumbler or water bottle: which should you choose?

A mug of coffee beside an open notebook on a wooden desk

All three will carry your photo. The difference is where they get used. A mug is for drinking at home or at a desk. A tumbler keeps a drink hot or cold while you are out. A bottle goes in a bag and gets you through the day. Here is how they compare in practice, using the cups in our range.

The short answer

MugTumblerWater bottle
Best forTea and coffee at home or at workThe commute, the car, the gardenThe gym, walks, days out
LidNoYes, often with a strawYes
Made ofCeramic or enamelMostly stainless steelStainless steel or plastic
WashingMost ceramic ones are dishwasher safeMostly hand-wash onlyBest washed by hand
ExampleWhite Glossy Mug, from £8.00Insulated Tumbler with a Straw, from £26.00Stainless Steel Water Bottle, from £31.00

Mugs: for home and the office

A ceramic mug is still the best cup for a hot drink you are going to sit down with. Our mugs start with the White Glossy Mug in 11 oz, 15 oz and 20 oz. There is also a Black Glossy Mug, a cone-shaped Latte Mug and the White Ceramic Mug with Colour Inside, which has a coloured rim, handle and inside.

Good points: the White Glossy, Black Glossy and Latte mugs are dishwasher and microwave safe, which makes them the easiest cups in the range to live with. Mugs also cost less than the insulated options.

Limits: no lid and no insulation. A mug is not something to carry to the car.

For the outdoors there is the Enamel Mug, a lightweight camping-style mug. It is hand-wash only. If you are choosing between mug sizes, see our guide to 11 oz, 15 oz and 20 oz mugs.

Tumblers: for drinks on the move

A tumbler is a tall cup with a lid, usually made of stainless steel. Our tumblers include:

Good points: an insulated tumbler keeps coffee hot, or a cold drink cold, for longer than an open mug will. The lid cuts down on spills.

Limits: a tumbler lid is not a seal. The product pages for the Insulated Tumbler with a Straw and the Wine Tumbler both say they are not leak-proof, so carry a tumbler upright in your hand or a cup holder and not loose in a bag. Most are hand-wash only, and nothing made of steel can go in a microwave.

Water bottles: for the bag

A bottle is the one to choose for the gym, a walk or a long day out. Our water bottles are:

Good points: bottles hold more, travel well and suit water all day long. The Stainless Steel Water Bottle is insulated for hot and cold drinks.

Limits: they cost more than a mug and are best washed by hand. Two of them are listed as hand-wash only.

What about glasses?

If the drink is cold and staying at home, there is glassware too: a can-shaped glass for iced coffee, a rocks glass, a stemless wine glass and a pint glass. None of them is dishwasher safe.

How the photo looks on each

The shape of the cup changes the shape of the print. A photo that fills the side of a mug sits differently on a tall, slim bottle. You do not have to guess which suits yours. Upload it in the preview studio on the homepage and compare it on a mug, a tumbler, a bottle and a glass side by side. Our guide to choosing a photo that prints well has more on what works.

So which one?

  • They drink tea at the kitchen table or at a desk: a mug.
  • They drive or commute with a coffee: a tumbler or the travel mug.
  • They go to the gym, walk the dog or always carry a bag: a bottle.
  • You are buying a gift and are not sure: a mug suits almost everyone. Our gift ideas by occasion may help.

Whichever you choose, read the care guide before the first wash.

More from the blog